Why Does the Answer About God's Name Come as "I Will Be What I Will Be"?
Why does the answer about God’s name come in the form “I Will Be What I Will Be” (Exodus 3:14) - how can a name be a message, a promise, and a riddle that accompanies an entire nation?
Moses asks: “What is His name, what shall I say to them?” (Exodus 3:13), and the Holy One, blessed be He, answers him with a name that sounds like a living sentence:
“And God said to Moses: I Will Be What I Will Be. And He said: Thus shall you say to the children of Israel: I Will Be has sent me to you.” (Exodus 3:14)
How can a name be a message, a promise, and a riddle all at once?
- Message - The name is “presence”, not “label”
Notice that before this name, the Holy One, blessed be He, already tells Moses: “For I will be with you” (Exodus 3:12).
In other words, the answer to the question of the name does not come as an abstract concept, but as an announcement: I am with you. Not “what I am”, but “how you will encounter Me”.
Insight: this is a name that forces you to step out of the dictionary and into life. “I Will Be” is almost “I am present, I accompany, I am with you inside the story”.
- Promise - “I am with them inside the suffering”
Rashi on the verse writes explicitly: “I will be with them in this affliction, as I will be with them in the servitude of other kingdoms” (Rashi on Exodus 3:14).
And in the Midrash there also appears the sharp dialogue in which Moses asks not to burden the people with future afflictions, in the words: “Sufficient is the trouble in its time” (Shemot Rabbah 3:6).
In other words, this name is a double promise:
-
Not a promise of “there will be no fire”
-
But a promise of “I am inside the fire with you”
- Riddle - Because the name does not “lock” God in, but leaves Him infinite
In that same Midrash appears an astonishing principle: “According to My deeds I am called” (Shemot Rabbah 3:6).
And in that same context it is also said: “I am the one who was, I am the one who is now, and I am the one who will be in the future” (Shemot Rabbah 3:6).
This is the depth of the riddle: the name does not come to place the Holy One, blessed be He, inside a single definition, but to say - you will know Me through My manifestations in reality, “according to My deeds”.
That is why “I Will Be What I Will Be” sounds like an open sentence: I will be with you as I will be - at every stage, in every situation, in every generation.
Closing insight: In Egypt, the people became numbers, bricks, statistics. And then this “name” arrives and says: you are not a number - you are a relationship. Not “what will be”, but “who will be with you”. This is a name that walks with an entire nation until the end of history.