Parashat Emor - Sixth Aliyah
Read the biblical text and try to understand it on your own, before reading the commentary.
The sixth aliyah closes the calendar of festivals. After Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur comes the festival of Sukkot, seven days from the fifteenth of Tishrei, followed by a separate eighth day which is also “Mikra kodesh” (verse 36), called by the Torah “Atseret”. The Torah binds this festival to two physical symbols: dwelling in the sukkah and taking the four species. Both demand that you do something with the body, not only pray and not only offer.
At the end of the chapter the Torah brings us back to memory: “Lema’an yed’u doroteichem ki vasukot hoshavti et bnei Yisrael behotsi’i otam me’erets Mitsrayim” (verse 43), so that your generations may know that I caused the children of Israel to dwell in booths when I brought them out of the land of Egypt. This is the surprising turn of Sukkot. It celebrates the harvest, the peak of the agricultural year, but it pulls you out of your built home and into a temporary structure, in order to remember that you did not always have a roof. At the moment of greatest abundance, the sukkah is the reminder.
A festival that begins in the body, not only in prayer
The sukkah is a bodily commandment. “Basukot teshvu shiv’at yamim” (verse 42). Prayer is not specifically what is done there, eating is, sleeping is, hosting guests is. The four species are also a bodily commandment, “Ulkachtem lachem” (verse 40), in your hands. The Torah is not satisfied with intent. It wants the hand to grip the branch, the body to enter beneath the covering. The holiness of Sukkot passes through matter.
The eighth day is its own festival, not a continuation
“Bayom hashmini mikra kodesh yih’yeh lachem… atseret hi” (verse 36). Shemini Atseret is not the eighth day of Sukkot, it is an independent festival. After seven days of dwelling in the sukkah, the Torah wants one more day, without sukkah and without lulav, only atseret. This is the moment when one says: do not continue the ceremony, halt. The seven days have built something, the eighth day stays with it. Without going back home.
The four species as a single bound bundle
The commandment of the four species requires taking four different plants and binding them together. Vayikra Rabbah 30:12 explains that they symbolize four kinds of people: the etrog with both taste and fragrance, the lulav with taste but no fragrance, the hadas with fragrance but no taste, and the arava with neither taste nor fragrance. The midrash concludes: “Yukshru kulam aguda achat vehen mechaperin elu al elu”, let them all be tied as one bundle and they atone for one another. The message is not romantic, it is structural. A single commandment is fulfilled only when all kinds are present together. Leaving out one species invalidates everything.
The time of harvest is precisely when one should leave the house
“Be’osfechem et tvu’at ha’arets tachogu et chag Adonai” (verse 39). Precisely when the storehouse is full, the Torah moves you to the sukkah. Instead of letting abundance go to one’s head, it is returned to memory. A person who feels successful at this time sits in the sukkah and remembers that what you have gathered today is not necessarily what you will keep tomorrow. Memory does not cancel joy, it balances it.
The sukkah opens an intergenerational memory
“Lema’an yed’u doroteichem” (verse 43). Sukkot is the only festival in the calendar to which the Torah attaches a commandment about transmission to future generations. Memory is not preserved in a book but in a commandment. A child who sits in a sukkah does not receive a theoretical explanation, he lives the answer. Each year again. This is a technology of memory: it is not enough to read, one must sit.
”Ani Adonai eloheichem” seals the entire calendar
The verses end with the recurring formula: “Ani Adonai eloheichem” (verse 43). After a long line of festivals, sacrifices, and prohibitions of work, the Torah returns the entire system to one statement. All the festivals, all the sukkot and all the four species lead back to the same basic relationship. One who keeps the festivals without knowing who took him out of Egypt keeps mitsvot but does not live inside the festival. A festival is not only a date, it is a relationship.
More Questions on the Parsha
More questions on this parsha are on the way. In the meantime, explore our daily Torah learning.
Daily Torah learning