Parashat Toldot - Third Aliyah
Read the biblical text and try to understand it on your own, before reading the commentary.
Isaac grows increasingly wealthy. He has flocks, herds and a large workforce, and the Philistines envy him. The Torah also tells of Abraham’s wells, which the Philistines stopped up and filled with earth. Finally, Abimelech demands that Isaac leave:
lech me’immanu ki atzamta mimmennu me’od
Translation: Go away from us, for you have become much stronger than we are.
Isaac moves to the valley of Gerar. Within this account, the Torah also describes the reopening of his father’s wells and the preservation of the names his father gave them. Genesis 26:13-18
Isaac’s servants dig in the valley and find a well of fresh spring water, but the shepherds of Gerar claim:
lanu hamayim
Translation: The water is ours.
The well is named Esek. They dig another well, and there is a dispute over it too; it is named Sitnah. Only after Isaac moves farther away and digs another well is there no dispute. He names it Rehoboth and says that God has made room for them and that they will be fruitful in the land. Genesis 26:19-22
Prosperity that brings envy
The blessing in the field does not promise Isaac an easy life among his neighbors. Precisely as he grows wealthy, his success proves to provoke resistance. Abimelech himself explains his demand that Isaac leave by pointing to Isaac’s strength. Genesis 26:13-16
This suggests a sober thought about success: prosperity solves one difficulty but can create other challenges in our relationships with those around us. Alongside great wealth appears an opposite image: wells filled with earth. A source of water that could have sustained people and livestock stands blocked.
Renewing without erasing the past
Isaac returns to his father’s wells and gives them the same names. Why does the Torah take care to mention the names too?
Rashbam explains that keeping the old names was meant to prevent others from challenging the claim to the wells. Radak adds that the names preserve their original possession. A name connects a well to its past and to the rights already established over it. Rashbam on Genesis 26:18, Radak on 26:18
From here, we can also widen our view to family continuity: Isaac acts in his own right, but he does not need to erase what Abraham built in order to build his own way. He restores the water source and keeps its name. This is renewal without severing ties, allowing the past to become a source of life in the present once again.
Sometimes room opens when we are willing to move
There is a dispute over each of the first two wells. Of the third, we read:
velo ravu aleha
Translation: They did not quarrel over it.
Radak explains that Isaac moved a little farther from their boundary, to a place where they could not challenge the claim to the well, because it clearly did not belong to Gerar. Moving away changed the conditions of the dispute. Genesis 26:22, Radak on the verse
This suggests a thought about handling quarrels: sometimes the way forward is not to remain in the same arena and try once more to win there, but to seek a place where we can build without renewing the same confrontation. Isaac keeps digging even as he changes location.
The name Rehoboth comes after Esek and Sitnah. First there is pressure, tension and conflict; only then does room open up. Isaac attributes that widening space to God, and the path he has traveled reminds us that room does not always come easily: sometimes the way to it involves patience, a willingness to change location and a choice not to be drawn into prolonged confrontations.
More Questions on the Parsha
Esau's Blessing Includes 'By Your Sword You Shall Live' and Dependence on His Brother. Is This a Curse, a Different Kind of Blessing, or a Description of a Nation That Lives in Perpetual Movement Between Rebellion and Subjugation?
An exploration of Isaac's blessing to Esau - part material blessing, part existential profile - examining how 'by your sword you shall live' reflects a dynamic fate of strength, conflict, and perpetual tension with Jacob.
Isaac Prays Facing His Wife: What Can We Learn About Shared Pain?
Rashi and Radak on Isaac’s prayer facing Rebecca, and what their readings can suggest about praying together in hardship.
Esek, Sitnah and Rehoboth: What Do Isaac’s Wells Teach About Conflict?
From the disputes over Esek and Sitnah to Rehoboth and the treaty at Beersheba, what can Isaac’s wells teach about conflict?
Esau Says “I Am Going to Die”: What Does He Mean?
Hunting danger, the responsibility of sacrificial service or denial of the world to come? Esau’s words and a careful comparison with life in danger.