Did Jacob Establish the Evening Prayer We Say Today?
Question: Did Jacob really establish the evening prayer? Have we been praying it with the same wording ever since?
Answer: The Sages connect the three daily prayers with the three patriarchs: Abraham established the morning prayer, Isaac the afternoon prayer, and Jacob the evening prayer. The wording familiar to us took shape in later generations, but the connection with Jacob gives the evening prayer a special meaning: turning to God even when the road is dark and the future is still unclear.
Prayer on the Road into the Unknown
Jacob leaves Beersheba on his way to Haran. The sun sets, and he stops for the night:
Vayifga bamakom vayalen sham ki va hashemesh.
Translation: He came upon the place and spent the night there, for the sun had set. (Genesis 28:11)
In Berakhot 26b, the Sages interpret the word vayifga as an expression of prayer, and learn from it that Jacob established the evening prayer. Rashi on the verse also brings this interpretation.
This prayer comes before the dream of the ladder and the promise of protection. We can find a beautiful message here: turning to God while still on the way, when we do not yet have the answers.
Not every prayer is born of calm and confidence. Some prayers arise precisely from uncertainty, from the need to find support when we do not know where the road leads. In Jacob’s night, we can see an invitation to this kind of connection: to pray even before the light comes.
From Jacob to the Wording of the Prayer Book
The words we say today are not a text handed down to us from Jacob’s prayer. Maimonides describes how, after the Babylonian exile, many people struggled to express their requests in Hebrew because their speech had become a mixture of languages. Ezra and his court established eighteen blessings in a set order, so that even someone who struggled to express themselves could offer a complete prayer.
The first three blessings praise God, the last three give thanks, and those in the middle contain requests for the needs of individuals and the community. In this way, personal prayer also gained a shared language: a person brings their life and needs into a prayer that connects them with the people of Israel as a whole.
The roots of the evening prayer thus lie in the tradition about Jacob, while the ordered blessings we encounter in the prayer book are the work of the Sages in later generations. The connection to the patriarchs and the shared wording come together also in the prayer we offer each evening.
Why Is the Evening Prayer Called Optional?
The Talmud also connects the prayers with the sacrificial service in the Temple. The evening prayer corresponds to the burning of the sacrificial limbs and fats, which continued during the night.
In Berakhot 27b, the Sages disagree over whether the evening prayer is obligatory or optional. Maimonides explains that although it was not established as an obligation like the morning and afternoon prayers, the people of Israel made a practice of praying it and accepted it as an obligatory prayer.
Turning Worry into Prayer
Years later, as his meeting with Esau approaches in Parashat Vayishlach, Jacob again faces a threatening future. He is afraid, divides his camp in two, and turns to God:
Hatzileni na miyad achi miyad Esav ki yare anochi oto.
Translation: Please deliver me from the hand of my brother, from the hand of Esau, for I fear him. (Genesis 32:12)
There is something touching about this prayer: Jacob tells God that he is afraid. He brings his worry as it is and asks for help. The words about fear are part of the prayer itself. A person of faith, too, can fear for their loved ones and ask for deliverance from the depths of their heart.
Alongside his prayer, Jacob prepares for the encounter and sends Esau a gift in an attempt to appease him. Dividing the camp, sending the gift, and asking God for help come together in a way of facing difficulty that includes both practical responsibility and faith. We can learn from him how to turn worry toward a request, and a sense of helplessness toward action.
In the evening, as the day’s activity quiets down, worries sometimes gain more room: what we did not manage to do today, what tomorrow will bring, and what will happen to the people dear to us. The evening prayer can be a moment in which we turn worry into prayer: we give it words before God, ask for help, and entrust to Him what lies beyond our power.
In this way, we can end the day by turning to God in faith, asking for strength and guidance for the next step within our power. Sometimes prayer begins precisely when we do not know what tomorrow will bring.