Parashat Toldot - Fifth Aliyah
Read the biblical text and try to understand it on your own, before reading the commentary.
Peace outside, bitterness at home
Isaac gives a feast for Abimelech and his men. The next morning they swear an oath to each other, and Isaac sends them away in peace. That same day, his servants report that they have found water in the well they dug. Isaac names the well Shivah, a name Rashi links to the covenant. In Abraham’s story too, the name Beersheba is linked to an oath with Abimelech. Genesis 26:30-33 · Rashi on 26:33 · Genesis 21:30-31
The Torah then turns to the family. Esau is forty when he marries two Hittite women, Judith and Basemath. His marriages bring Isaac and Rebecca grief. The change is abrupt. One moment Isaac sends his guests away in peace, and the next we hear of bitterness at home. The verses that follow show how far apart Isaac and Rebecca are on which son should receive the blessing. Genesis 26:31-35 · Genesis 27:1-10
What does Rebecca know?
Isaac grows old and his sight dims. He calls Esau and asks him to hunt and prepare the food he loves so he can bless him before he dies. Rebecca overhears the conversation and sends Jacob to fetch two young goats. She will prepare the food, and Jacob will take it to Isaac to receive the blessing. Genesis 27:1-10
Ramban takes us back to Rebecca’s pregnancy, when she sought God and heard that the older would serve the younger. He suggests that Rebecca never told Isaac about the prophecy. In his reading, Isaac means to pass Abraham’s blessing on to Esau, his firstborn, while Rebecca acts on what she was told before the twins were born. As Isaac prepares to bless Esau, each of them holds a different part of the family’s story. Genesis 25:22-23 · Ramban on 27:4
The voice and the hands
Jacob fears that his father will touch him and discover that his skin is smooth, while Esau is hairy. If Isaac thinks Jacob is trying to deceive him, he may curse him instead of blessing him. Rebecca tells Jacob that if his father curses him, the curse will fall on her. She dresses him in Esau’s clothes and covers his hands and the smooth part of his neck with the goatskins. Jacob’s fear comes down to a practical question: what happens when Father touches me? Genesis 27:11-17
When Jacob introduces himself as Esau, Isaac asks how he found game so quickly. Jacob says that God brought it his way. According to Rashi, the mention of God arouses Isaac’s suspicion because Esau does not usually speak that way. Isaac asks to feel his son. The hands feel like Esau’s, but the voice sounds like Jacob’s. Even after touching him, Isaac asks again whether he is Esau. Jacob answers with a single word.
ani
Translation: I am.
Genesis 27:18-24 · Rashi on 27:21
Isaac eats the food, drinks the wine, and asks his son to come close and kiss him. Jacob approaches, and when Isaac smells his clothes, he compares his son’s scent to that of a field God has blessed. Genesis 27:25-27
Earlier in the reading, Isaac sends Esau out to the field. At the end, the scent of the field reaches him on Esau’s clothes, worn by Jacob. The scent has already found its way into the blessing. In the next reading, we’ll listen to the blessing Isaac gives with one question still hanging in the air: who does he think he’s blessing?
More Questions on the Parsha
Esau's Blessing Includes 'By Your Sword You Shall Live' and Dependence on His Brother. Is This a Curse, a Different Kind of Blessing, or a Description of a Nation That Lives in Perpetual Movement Between Rebellion and Subjugation?
An exploration of Isaac's blessing to Esau - part material blessing, part existential profile - examining how 'by your sword you shall live' reflects a dynamic fate of strength, conflict, and perpetual tension with Jacob.
Isaac Prays Facing His Wife: What Can We Learn About Shared Pain?
Rashi and Radak on Isaac’s prayer facing Rebecca, and what their readings can suggest about praying together in hardship.
Esek, Sitnah and Rehoboth: What Do Isaac’s Wells Teach About Conflict?
From the disputes over Esek and Sitnah to Rehoboth and the treaty at Beersheba, what can Isaac’s wells teach about conflict?
Esau Says “I Am Going to Die”: What Does He Mean?
Hunting danger, the responsibility of sacrificial service or denial of the world to come? Esau’s words and a careful comparison with life in danger.