Parashat Toldot - Sixth Aliyah
Read the biblical text and try to understand it on your own, before reading the commentary.
The blessing and Esau’s cry
At the end of the previous aliyah, Isaac smells Esau’s clothes on Jacob and compares his son’s scent to that of a field God has blessed. Now he blesses the son before him with the dew of heaven, the richness of the earth, and abundant grain and wine. Along with that abundance, he gives him authority over his brothers and rule over nations. Genesis 27:27-29
Jacob has barely left his father when Esau comes in with the food he prepared. Isaac again asks who is standing before him. When he hears that it is Esau, his firstborn, he trembles. In his distress he says that the one he already blessed “shall indeed be blessed.” Drawing on Genesis Rabbah, Rashi explains that Isaac “therefore agreed and blessed him knowingly.” In this reading, the moment Isaac discovers the deception is the very moment he knowingly confirms the blessing he already gave. Genesis 27:30-33 · Rashi on Genesis 27:33
gam baruch yihyeh
Translation: He shall indeed be blessed.
Esau lets out a loud, bitter cry. He brings up the birthright alongside the blessing and describes both as things Jacob took from him. Then he asks whether his father has only one blessing. Isaac mentions the richness of the earth and the dew of heaven in his words to Esau too. He also speaks of living by the sword, serving his brother, and one day breaking free of his yoke. Even as he receives a blessing of his own, Esau hears again where he stands in relation to Jacob. Genesis 27:34-40
How does revenge become a comfort?
Esau hates Jacob because of the blessing and plans to kill him after their father dies. When Rebecca tells Jacob, she uses a surprising word: Esau is “taking comfort.” Rashi gives several readings. In his plain-sense reading, Esau “comforts himself over the blessings by killing you.” After hearing Esau cry and weep, we hear something else in that word. The thought of revenge already offers him comfort for what he lost, before he has done anything. Genesis 27:38-42 · Rashi on Genesis 27:42
mitnachem
Translation: Taking comfort.
Two conversations, one journey
Rebecca fears losing both sons in a single day. She tells Jacob to flee to her brother Laban in Haran and wait for Esau’s anger to subside. With Isaac she raises a concern we have already encountered. Esau’s Hittite wives have caused them both grief, and Rebecca fears that Jacob too will marry a woman from the land. The same departure takes on a different meaning in each conversation. Rebecca sends Jacob away from danger, and Isaac sends him to his mother’s family to start a family of his own. Genesis 26:34-35 · Genesis 27:42-46 · Genesis 28:1-2
This time Isaac calls Jacob
Isaac tells Jacob to go to Paddan Aram and marry one of Laban’s daughters. Before he leaves, Isaac blesses him with descendants and asks that he become an assembly of peoples. He asks that Abraham’s blessing pass to Jacob and his descendants so that they may inherit the land given to Abraham. Genesis 28:1-4
At the end of the fifth aliyah we were left wondering whom Isaac thought he was blessing. At the end of this aliyah, Isaac calls Jacob himself. This time he knows who is standing before him, and he names what he wishes to pass on to him and his children: Abraham’s blessing.
More Questions on the Parsha
Esau's Blessing Includes 'By Your Sword You Shall Live' and Dependence on His Brother. Is This a Curse, a Different Kind of Blessing, or a Description of a Nation That Lives in Perpetual Movement Between Rebellion and Subjugation?
An exploration of Isaac's blessing to Esau - part material blessing, part existential profile - examining how 'by your sword you shall live' reflects a dynamic fate of strength, conflict, and perpetual tension with Jacob.
Isaac Prays Facing His Wife: What Can We Learn About Shared Pain?
Rashi and Radak on Isaac’s prayer facing Rebecca, and what their readings can suggest about praying together in hardship.
Esek, Sitnah and Rehoboth: What Do Isaac’s Wells Teach About Conflict?
From the disputes over Esek and Sitnah to Rehoboth and the treaty at Beersheba, what can Isaac’s wells teach about conflict?
Esau Says “I Am Going to Die”: What Does He Mean?
Hunting danger, the responsibility of sacrificial service or denial of the world to come? Esau’s words and a careful comparison with life in danger.