Parashat Noach - Third Aliyah

The mountaintops are already visible, yet the dove still cannot find a place to rest. The ark has come to rest, yet Noah does not leave. The flood recedes gradually, and the Torah lingers over the distance between the first sign of change and the possibility of beginning again.

Rescue does not end inside the ark

The turning point comes at the beginning of chapter 8:

vayizkor Elohim et Noach ve’et kol hachayah ve’et kol habehemah asher ito batevah vayaaver Elohim ruach al ha’aretz vayashoku hamayim

Translation: God remembered Noah and all the wild animals and livestock with him in the ark. God sent a wind over the earth, and the waters subsided.

Genesis 8:1

Why does this remembrance include the animals too?

Ramban distinguishes between Noah and the animals. Noah is remembered because of his righteousness and the covenant made with him. The remembrance of the animals concerns God’s desire for the world, and the species He created, to endure. They must therefore be brought out of the ark so that they do not perish inside it. Ramban on Genesis 8:1

According to this interpretation, keeping life safe inside the ark is only part of the rescue. Life must also be able to continue in the world. The place that protected them during the flood cannot be their home forever.

What does the dove discover that Noah cannot see?

After the ark comes to rest and the mountaintops appear, Noah sends the dove to see whether the waters have diminished. She returns:

velo matze’ah hayonah mano’ach lechaf raglah vatashov elav el hatevah ki mayim al pnei chol ha’aretz vayishlach yado vayikacheha vayave otah elav el hatevah

Translation: The dove found no resting place for the sole of her foot and returned to him in the ark, because water covered the surface of the whole earth. He reached out his hand, took her and brought her into the ark with him.

Genesis 8:9

But if the mountains are already exposed, why is there nowhere for her to rest?

Sforno explains that even the visible mountaintops were still very wet, so the dove could find no resting place for the sole of her foot there. Sforno on Genesis 8:9

His distinction gives meaning to this small detail: ground that can be seen is not necessarily ground one can rest on. The dove tests what the sight of the mountains alone cannot establish.

When she returns, Noah reaches out his hand and brings her in. In a story of such widespread destruction, the Torah pauses over a gesture toward one creature who has found no place outside.

A small leaf, two meanings

Seven days later, the dove is sent out again:

vatavo elav hayonah le’et erev vehineh aleh zayit taraf befiha vayeda Noach ki kalu hamayim me’al ha’aretz

Translation: The dove came to him toward evening, with a freshly plucked olive leaf in her beak. Noah knew that the waters had diminished over the earth.

Genesis 8:11

In the plain meaning of the verse, the leaf tells Noah that the waters have diminished. Reading the verse on that level, Ramban infers that the trees were not uprooted by the flood: the dove found a leaf from a tree that remained outside. Ramban on Genesis 8:11

Rashi cites a midrash that gives the olive leaf another meaning: a preference for bitter food from God’s hand over sweet food dependent on human beings. Rashi on Genesis 8:11

The same detail thus carries two readings: evidence of the condition of the world outside, and a hint of what life beyond human shelter can mean.

Before the departure

The next time, the dove does not return. This can be read as a moment when the creature who received shelter no longer needs to come back to it. Noah, by contrast, remains even after seeing that the surface of the ground had dried.

The aliyah ends before the departure. The flood has passed, but the story of rescue is not yet complete: the lives preserved in the ark must now find their place in the world that follows.

More Questions on the Parsha

More questions on this parsha are on the way. In the meantime, explore our daily Torah learning.

Daily Torah learning